Reviews

they used to make real sandwichs

stopped by for a roast beef with mayo salt pepper and two slices of tomato, got home to eat it, it had 3 thin slices of roast beef, I paid 11.25 for this sandwich, I was very dissipointed I could have bought a pound of roast beef and made three sandwiches ... read more

sebastion9 via tripadvisor.com - Sep 27, 2021

Amazing array of fresh food and meats and breads.

debbie Salatti via google.com - Sep 15, 2021

Always get party heroes from here! Never have an issue, always ready on time and taste delicious!!

KATHERINE LA CASSE via google.com - Jul 6, 2021

Delicious food, great atmosphere, excellent waitstaff. Had a delightful dinner.

Catherine Hugues via facebook.com - Jun 20, 2021

molto attrezzato vasto assortimento di prodotti ... read more

Carmine Famiglietti via google.com - May 31, 2021

Great deli ... read more

Gerald Hall via google.com - May 26, 2021

Always first class food.. Absolutely delicious everything they have yes it's a little bit pricey but it's worth every cent ... read more

Erin Daly via google.com - May 23, 2021

The best Italian speciality store out there! I love Maria’s new creations that she makes daily, especially her mozzarella in carrozza!

Gino Cosentino via google.com - May 22, 2021

Absolutely positively delicious heros made by Nick...excellent coldcuts eggplant chicken cutlets..omg the pasta fasoool outta this world...frittata spinach...I'm fainting delicious...I'll be back!!!!

Susan Lombardi via google.com - May 17, 2021

High quality foods which are definitely worth the premium.

Dan Dickmann via google.com - May 8, 2021

Love going there for bread and their quiche. Always plenty of good stuff ... read more

Gary Weiner via google.com - Apr 27, 2021

Fabulous. Meats...Sides ...Service ... read more

Nick DiSabatino via google.com - Apr 22, 2021

Place is absolutely great ... read more

Raymond Kohlberg via google.com - Apr 7, 2021

Food is always fresh ... read more

Nydre72 via google.com - Mar 24, 2021

Everything is always delicious ... read more

Stefania Torres via google.com - Mar 10, 2021

It's like walking though my Sicilian grandmother's pantry filled with Italian delicacies and staples. Breads, meats and prepared foods are exceptional. Even has produce making it a one-stop shopping experience for a meal. I dare you not to overspend your budget.

Jason Cascone via google.com - Feb 25, 2021

Very friendly, quick, in store shopping. Numerous prepared foods.

Kathie Ferrandino via google.com - Jan 18, 2021

We ordered 2 roast beef hero’s today . I must say they were super fresh and filling! The staff was

We ordered 2 roast beef hero’s today . I must say they were super fresh and filling! The staff was super nice and the place is well kept. This will probably be our new go to for lunches!

Deb East via facebook.com - Nov 15, 2020

Great meats and produce...awesome place!

Trineise Jennings via google.com - Nov 4, 2020

freshest, most delicious food around. Best Italian deli I have ever been to.

John Maio via facebook.com - Oct 26, 2020

All I can say delicious!!!

Patrica Hawxhurst via google.com - Oct 11, 2020

Always a delight to visit when in Babylon!

David Alubowicz via google.com - Sep 27, 2020

Great people great food ... read more

M M via google.com - Sep 9, 2020

Just basic Italian food. Not a great selection but it's good for "in a hurry" commitment ... read more

Angye Levy via google.com - Aug 29, 2020

seafood pasta was perfect!

James Campbell via facebook.com - Aug 29, 2020

Oh my God I lived here my whole life my first time here will never go anywhere for salads or cold cuts even prepared meat this place is great ... read more

steve aylward via google.com - Aug 8, 2020

I can't say enough about this deli/butcher/Italian specialties store. Absolutely LOVE everything they offer. You will find an array of fresh salads and other prepared foods made daily, most served by the pound or piece. Olives. Fresh mozzarella. Delicious deli sandwiches using Boar's Head products. A variety of freshly made breads & ... read more

Jackie V via google.com - Jul 29, 2020

Great place, food. Awesome family ... read more

Ann Marie Bove via google.com - Jul 19, 2020

Great food and friendly environment.

John Henricksen via google.com - Jul 17, 2020

Been going here for years, alot less than I want to over past few years because of moving out of the area. Never been dissapointed with any of the meats there.

David Sprague via google.com - Jul 11, 2020

Everyone in the Babylon area and beyond are aware of Gemelli's. This store is nothing short of amazing. Consistently the highest standards possible. I've been going for 20+ years and NEVER had a bad experience.

Joe Delorenzo via google.com - Jul 10, 2020

Love this place

If you ever wished there was a good butcher/old school kinda market then this is the place to go.The best selection of everything!

Happiness77192 via tripadvisor.com - Jun 12, 2020

The staff goes above and beyond to keep their customers happy. The food is delicious and authentic. My first visit was yesterday and I will certainly be back many more times!

Lauryn Lessing via google.com - Jun 1, 2020

The service alone earns them 45 stars. Great selection of food. I realy can't say enough about the shopping experience every week. Thank you guys for you treated my wheelchair bound friend and his aid, she is my wife..1yachtcarpenter~google it..

1 yacht carpenter via google.com - May 24, 2020

Great place great people. Can't ask for a better place to find any Italian delicacy. Outstanding meats. Wonderful selection. Everything cut to order. Always fresh. The veal cutlet were the best I've ever had. Love this place! You guys know me as Cookie.

Dee Christ via google.com - May 1, 2020

Great stuff and no no relation

Great stuff and no no relation ... read more

John Gemelli via facebook.com - Mar 31, 2020

Great selection of meats and fresh salads/sides. Top shelf products

Great selection of meats and fresh salads/sides. Top shelf products ... read more

Timothy Patrick via facebook.com - Mar 22, 2020

Food is excellent as well as the service ... read more

Dennis Killane via google.com - Mar 19, 2020

Very satisfied. Great selection thank you

Very satisfied. Great selection thank you ... read more

Sophie Kelly via facebook.com - Mar 7, 2020

Excellent beef and other meats!!! Prompt and courteous service....I enjoy talking with the employe

Excellent beef and other meats!!! Prompt and courteous service....I enjoy talking with the employees, all of them!

Eric Aull via facebook.com - Feb 10, 2020

Just the best can't say more ... read more

Peter Vitale via google.com - Jan 19, 2020

Very pricey $$%$ ... read more

Louie MASSARI via google.com - Jan 11, 2020

Great fresh raviolis ... read more

August Lentricchia via google.com - Dec 30, 2019

Love all their charcuterie, and their chicken sausages/chicken burgers for the bbq ... read more

Fula Icaza via google.com - Dec 29, 2019

Great food love their Seafood salads...

Frank Greco via google.com - Dec 23, 2019

Great food love their Seafood salads...

Frank VET.1776 via google.com - Dec 23, 2019

Good food and products!

Giuseppe Diliberto via google.com - Dec 19, 2019

Very nice store and restaurant, best food you can buy and very knowledgeable experienced chefs!

Gappsi Giuseppe Abbrancati via google.com - Dec 10, 2019

Great selection of Italian food. Very nice service ... read more

Edgar Borrero via google.com - Dec 5, 2019

Everything there looks great!

Geri King via google.com - Dec 2, 2019

Authentic Italian Deli. Food is excellent! Tremendous variety. Reminds me of the old style Italian Stores from my youth.

Ria Klaum via google.com - Dec 1, 2019

Excellent food and catering for the holidays!

Deborah Lyons-Birsner via google.com - Nov 28, 2019

Love this place, authentic Italian specialties, meats any thing you can imagine.

John Maio via google.com - Nov 26, 2019

High priced but you get what u pay for... except for the skirt steak ... read more

Peter Poggioli via google.com - Nov 17, 2019

Reasonable pricing on selection.

JOHN OGORMAN via google.com - Nov 15, 2019

Prices seem higher than other areas, but selection is very good. Try the gemelli burger with marinade in the chuck.

Jason O via google.com - Sep 29, 2019

Have to say this store looks and works better than before. Clean, stocked and great deli counter. I was impressed. It used to be a horror show. Now 5 stars!

Barbara Mason via google.com - Sep 26, 2019

Knowledgeable and pleasant staff

Knowledgeable and pleasant staff ... read more

Dorothy Montanez via facebook.com - Sep 24, 2019

Gemelli's is a classic Italian American high end deli. They serve homemade pastas and take home dinners. The sausage, cheese and olive oil selections are extensive and should encourage newcomers to try something new.

Valeria Matthews via google.com - Sep 5, 2019

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Follow Us

Navigation

Hours

Contact